Money on your mind?

It’s time to get your financial life together - fill out the form
Email subscribers get free access to my #GYFLT Worksheet, which includes my 5 step plan to get you feeling more in control of your finances.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Is it Your Debt and My Debt or Our Debt?

   Posted On: June 3, 2016  |    Posted In: Love and Money  |     Posted by: Broke Millennial®

Our DebtBeing relatively transparent about the financial state of a romantic relationship certainly isn’t the norm for most people. It is, however, the norm that Peach and I choose to live. While I don’t go spouting off his exact debt load, we’ve been vocal about the fact that I’ve lived a delightfully debt free life and he’s saddled with student loans. The fact that I’ve fallen in love with a man who comes with the baggage of debt means we’ve spoken ad nauseum about our strategy for handling money post-nuptials.

Before people get excited, no, we are not engaged*, we just talk about this stuff openly, honestly, and probably a little too often.

I’ve written about getting financially naked before and routinely spout off about my opinion that couples should work jointly in handling money and share their ledgers before marriage. However, there’s something about hearing me talk about it and allowing Peach to vocalize his opinion himself instead of through the lens of my writing that seems to have struck some folks, including my mother. But first, let me back up.

Peach and I ventured into the depths of Brooklyn last week to record an episode for one of my favorite podcasts, The Paper Year. It’s not a money podcast (because I do actually consume non-personal finance content). The Paper Year is chronicling the hosts’ first year of marriage. Each episode, the hosts Evan and Caitlin talk to a different couple in various states of matrimony, or in one case divorce, and the often 1.5 hour long conversation is a deep dive into the couple’s backstory and strategies for relationship success.

After binging the first seven episodes, I expressed my enthusiasm for listening to complete strangers talk about their love lives on Twitter.

Screen Shot 2016-06-02 at 4.50.01 PM

This little interaction ultimately turned into an invite to be on the show. I was quick to offer a disclaimer that Peach and I aren’t actually married, but luckily, Evan and Caitlin decided not to discriminate against us singles.

Peach, who has always wanted to be a shock jock, leapt at the opportunity to do a podcast and finally get to defend his stance on finances in person! I jest – sort of.

The episode went live on Monday, so it’s been fun to hear people’s reactions to learning more about our relationship with each other and our individual relationships with money.

I spoke to my mom on the phone after she finished listening and she noted that she’d never really heard anyone speak about debt in the way we do. I feel strongly that it’s not a “yours or mine” situation but an “our” relationship with debt after marriage. Once those legal documents are signed, we’re in this thing together!

the paper year Instead of further explaining my stance, I offer you a transcript of the conversation which includes Peach’s feelings on the matter. I highly encourage you to listen to the full episode, but if you just want to hear what Peach and I sound like whilst speaking about our debt plan, then skip ahead to minute 59 when this all starts.

Editor note: I did make this a little easier to read so some sections aren’t exactly word-for-word because I cut out the space fillers or added names instead of pronouns. 

Evan (the host): “I had massive credit card debt. I had quite a bit. I told Caitlin, I don’t want to combine our finances until I pay that down.”

Caitlin: “They’re [Peach and I] sharing really cute looks right now as if you’re telling a romantic story. I love that this is romance for you guys.”

Evan: “I wanted to keep our finances separate, so that I could pay the money so that it wasn’t Caitlin’s debt that she had to pay, because that just felt kind of unfair.”

Peach: “We’ve spoken about this in depth. You know, when we do get married it theoretically becomes our debt.”

Me: “It does become our debt.”

Peach: “Even though it’s my student loan debt and she’s very comfortable with maybe one person’s salary going towards living expenses and with the other one we just try to destroy the debt as quickly as we can. And it’s nice because I don’t feel like it’s her just trying to do it for me. The conversations and the way that we talk about it is a we’re going to do it together and we’re going to figure this out as a team.”

Me: “Well, he started where you [Evan] are. When we first talked about this, maybe about three years ago I want to say, it was a ‘this is my debt, I’ll deal with it.’ And I said, ‘okay for now that’s fine, but when we’re married it’s not your debt it’s our debt because that debt impacts my life. Like if we’re getting a mortgage, anything like that, the debt comes into play. So if I’m making enough that I can support us as a couple and our day-to-day living expenses and some of your money goes to savings and the rest goes to debt and we can eliminate that in like a year or two, why wouldn’t we do that? Because then it’s just done. And we can also hit next phases faster if we’re working as a team and combining our income.’ It did take a while for you [Peach] to come around to that idea because you felt ownership.”

Peach: “Yeah.”

Me: “You felt like, this is yours I don’t want to burden you. This shouldn’t be an albatross in our relationship.”


The conversation continues, but alas, I got tired of transcribing so you can finish it out by listening to the podcast episode. Some of the highest praise I received was from my mom about how she really appreciated our joint mentality on how to handle our finances in the future, after all, money is a common source of tension in a marriage. We may not always see eye-to-eye on how to spend our money (*cough* comic books *cough*), but at least we’re open about the communication factor.

In case you were wondering, Peach officially went public with this episode. The reason for his nickname is that his last name is pronounced “Peachy”. I also do call him Peach in real life, as you’ll hear on the podcast.


*We’re engaged now and will be married in September 2018.

Like this post?

Fill out the form below to never miss another. You'll also get a free money worksheet.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

23 responses to “Is it Your Debt and My Debt or Our Debt?

    1. I love to hear that! I do look forward to the day Peach and I have joint finances, but not before rings are on both our fingers!

  1. Found you through The Paper Year and immediately opened a new savings account– I now have separate accounts for Travel/Extras and Emergencies. Just opening my online banking makes me feel more in control of my money.

    Thanks for all the great advice; keep it coming!

    1. Thanks so much for stopping by and I’m glad to hear it motivated you to open a new savings account! I’m all about the separate savings accounts.

  2. I relate to your last several posts — I’m also the breadwinner, not married, and now I’m debt-free, but my partner still has a lot of student loans. We don’t really plan on getting married (not important to me), but we still have to navigate this. So far, it’s worked out that I pay the rent, while he pays extra toward his student loan. It works for us, for now. I think it’s important to always check in!

    1. I love that you have a plan, especially if you know you want to share your lives together but don’t plan on making it a legal entity in terms of marriage. I think it’s important to me from a legal perspective more than anything else. But I also view marriage as more of a business transaction than normal people probably do. Big fan of pre-nups!

  3. I’ve been married for 10 years, but the husband and I lived together before we were married. He had zero debt when I met him, but I had student loans and car loans. We definitely saw it as “our” debt though, and were both on board with nixing it as soon as possible. That attitude has served us well in our marriage.

    1. Thanks so much for sharing your story. It always encourages me to hear that the “our” mentality serves people well.

  4. Interesting perspective! You guys clearly have a good handle on it and are working as a team. Honestly, I’m not sure what my husband and I would do if only one of us had debt or if we had drastically different salaries (we currently earn the exact same salary). Since we both have high student loan debt, we’re each paying extra on our own loans for now.

    1. That makes total sense and one reason it’s so important to just have open communication on the topic!

  5. We combined our money fully and while my husband paid off his debt before we got married I would have supported the debt paying efforts by using only 1 salary like you mention. As you said it does impact the joint financial picture for any major purchases in the future like a house. We combined our money the minute we bought our house but we were having open conversations about money about 6 months before that. Great job on having open conversations about money – but it’s really hard thing to do but you should be proud of how you guys manage things. I’m going to check out that podcast. Thanks for sharing,

    1. Thanks, Sarah! I agree that joint banking is just the way to go to simplify everything and promote transparency. We may each have an individual checking or savings so we can buy gifts and the like, but I think we’d have the ability to be able to check each other’s or something like that. Guess we’ll cross that bridge when we get there!

    1. That open communication is key for sure! Peach and I have different relationships to money and how we spend. I wouldn’t say he’s terrible, but he makes choices I wouldn’t and vice versa. It’s a fine line to decide when to nit pick a bit.

    1. I LOVED it! It’s such a great podcast to begin with, so it was really an honor to be asked to go on it.

  6. I think its great you two are so open about your debt and talk about it now like that. It will only help you two in the future.

    Lucky for my wife, I was able to help her get rid of all her debt before we got married but I wouldve considered it “our debt” after we were officially husband and wife.

    1. I could absolve Peach of his debt now, but I’m not willing to do so until after we’re actually married. It would make him uncomfortable and make me a bit weary of offering that up without the legal obligation of being committed to each other. Heaven forbid we didn’t end up getting married…

  7. It is definitely OUR debt. The Hubby got the short end of the stick here since I came into our marriage with the most debt. But we’ve talked about it in length and have come into this marriage understanding that what’s mine is yours and vice versa.

    1. Love! Glad to hear you two are on the same page like we are. Bet it takes a lot of the stress off these discussions.

  8. Hello, I have different relationships to money and how we spend. I wouldn’t say he’s terrible, but he makes choices I wouldn’t and vice versa.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *